Battle of the Pews – not over yet.

Seems the battle of the pews in Bath Abbey is not over yet after all.

The Victorian Society has applied for leave to appeal against the recent judgement in favour of removing the nave pews from the historic church.

Bath Abbey
Bath Abbey interior

Late last year the Chancellor of the Diocese of Bath and Wells granted permission for Bath Abbey to remove the Victorian pews from the abbey nave as part of their multi-million pound ‘Footprint’ project.

The pews were designed by renowned architect Sir George Gilbert Scott and are an almost complete set, unusual for churches of this size.

Screen Shot 2018-01-11 at 13.35.00
How the news of the appeal appears on the Victorian Society’s website.

In a statement – released today, Thursday, December 11th, the Victorian Society say they believe:
“The permanent removal of the Gilbert Scott pews is unnecessary and would harm the significance of the Grade I-listed building. We objected to the plans when they were first issued and eventually became party opponents at the Consistory Court hearing which took place within the abbey in October 2017.”

Christopher Costelloe, Director of the Victorian Society
Christopher Costelloe, Director of the Victorian Society

Christopher Costelloe, Director of the Victorian Society, said: “We were disappointed with the Chancellor’s decision to allow the pews to be removed, but believe we have strong grounds to appeal against the judgement. We are continuing to fight against a decision which we believe would cause significant harm to an outstanding listed building.”


bath abbey

Bath Abbey’s ‘Footprint’ project involves the removal of the Gilbert Scott pews from the nave and aisles in order to install contemporary underfloor heating. The Victorian Society is objecting to the abbey’s plans to make that removal permanent and to instead replace the pews with new seating.
The pews were designed by Sir George Gilbert Scott who was one of the Victorian era’s most celebrated architects and is best known for designing London’s St Pancras Station and the Albert Memorial. His major restoration of Bath Abbey in 1859-74 – says the Victorian Society – was intended to ‘complete’ the church as it would have been if the Reformation had not stopped its construction.

bath abbey
The central aisle inside Bath Abbey


The Society says the nave pews, which would be lost if this scheme is permitted, are unique to the abbey and are excellent examples of Scott’s work, each one modelled on those in other 16th century Somerset churches.
James Hughes, Churches Conservation Adviser for the Victorian Society, said: “We received significant public support for our campaign to save the Gilbert Scott pews, including over 1500 signatures on our online petition and dozens of comments and letters from the public expressing outrage that they may be lost forever.

There is clearly strong feeling, from the general public and Bath residents alike, that the pews are irreplaceable and significant to the historic and architectural importance of the Abbey.”

A Bath Abbey spokesperson said the church would wait to see if an appeal IS allowed before making any official comment.


1 Comment

  1. I’d like to say that the sooner these ghastly pews go, the better. They’re dark, gloomy and uncomfortable. They don’t belong in this church which early prints show to be an open space. How can I register my opinion in favour of the pews’ removal?

Comments are closed.